This book provides a critical analysis of the principle of mutual recognition of judicial decisions in criminal matters in the European Union through a detailed assessment of its most prominent instrument, the European Arrest Warrant (EAW). It conceptualizes and contextualizes the lack of clear vision in the building up of the area of freedom, security, and justice from an EU constitutional law, as well as a comparative and international criminal law standpoint. The EAW is considered both as a test for all the other measures which have been adopted or will be adopted as part of the mutual recognition agenda, and as an evolution of classic extradition. On the one hand, its significance is viewed from the perspective of both EU law and international law, by highlighting the structural deficiencies of the former Third Pillar and the need to remedy them. On the other hand, its impact is verified not only in the context of European cooperation in criminal matters, but also in light of the more general question of the identity of the EU as a polity, as well as the nature and implications of EU integration after the entry into force of the Treaty of Lisbon. In particular, the book revolves around four main issues: 1) the need to substantially re-define the concept of mutual recognition; 2) the extent to which the new mechanism of the EAW effectively operates within a non-harmonized landscape; 3) the exact nature and scope of mutual trust, as a notion that underpins the principle of mutual recognition in European criminal law; and 4) the tension between the need to enhance the law enforcement aspects of EU cooperation and the urge to build up a common framework of procedural rights. An overview of the implementation of the EAW in the UK and Italy, as examples of a common law and a civil law jurisdiction, is also offered.
About the Author: Massimo Fichera is currently Lecturer in European Studies at the Network for European Studies, University of Helsinki. His interests lie in constitutional theory and the intersection between EU and international law from an interdisciplinary perspective. He has published a monograph and two co-edited books, as well as a number of articles covering the area of freedom, security and justice, EU law, transnational law and same-sex marriage. He has been a Visiting Researcher at the International Institute for the Sociology of Law (IISL), Oñati (Spain) and is a member of various associations, including the International Association of Constitutional Law. In the past he has given lectures in several academic institutions, such as the Max Planck Institute for Foreign and International Criminal Law and the IISL. He was previously a Post-Doctoral Fellow at the Faculty of Law, University of Helsinki. Before joining the University of Helsinki, he completed his PhD at the University of Edinburgh and carried out research during his internships in international organisations, including the European Commission and the United Nations. He holds a degree in Law (University of Messina) and a Master in International Affairs (ISPI, Milan) and qualified as lawyer in Italy.